Vagobond

Books and Writing that Matter. Travel fiction, philosophy, memoir, and experimental work from the road.

Blues People by Amiri Baraka: Music as Black American History

The Beat Century — post 40 of 100. Amiri Baraka, Blues People (1963).

Cover of Blues People by Amiri Baraka
Blues People, 1963. Cover image via Open Library.

Published in 1963 under the name LeRoi Jones, Blues People was the first full-length study of jazz and blues by an African American writer, and it argued that the music is the history.

William Morrow published Blues People: Negro Music in White America in 1963. The author was twenty-eight and writing as LeRoi Jones; he would take the name Amiri Baraka a few years later, after Malcolm X’s assassination. The book runs to twelve chapters and 244 pages, and it was the first full-length analytical and historical study of jazz and blues written by an African American.

That fact is worth sitting with before anything else. By 1963 jazz criticism was an established profession with its own canon of authorities, and essentially all of them were white. Baraka’s book is not only an argument about music. It is a claim of jurisdiction — an assertion that the people who produced this music are competent to theorise it.

The Argument

Baraka’s thesis is that Black music constitutes a historical record of African American consciousness — not an accompaniment to that history but its primary documentation. Where written records were forbidden, forged, or produced by other people, the music kept an accurate account, and it can be read. The music is treated throughout as thought, produced by people whose thinking the historical record was designed not to preserve.

The twelve chapters move chronologically: African musical retention and adaptation, the conditions of slavery, work songs and spirituals, the emergence of blues, the Classic Blues period, urban migration and commercialisation, swing and its mainstreaming, and bebop as a deliberate revolt. Each transition in musical form is treated as evidence of a transition in social position. Baraka’s central historical claim is that the shift from African to African American — from a captive to a person born into a country that would not have him — is legible in the music before it is legible anywhere else.

Appropriation as a Structural Feature

The subtitle does the work the title does not: Negro Music in White America. Baraka’s account is not simply a story of invention; it is a story of invention followed reliably by extraction. Each innovation originates in Black communities, is commercially absorbed and smoothed into white popular forms, and is then answered by a new innovation deliberately constructed to be harder to take. Bebop, in this reading, is not merely an aesthetic development but a defensive one — music built at a speed and harmonic complexity designed to resist the swing industry’s absorption.

His broader claim is stated flatly: “the only so-called popular music in this country of any real value is of African derivation.” That sentence was a provocation in 1963 and it functions as the book’s spine — the assertion that Black musical innovation is not a tributary of American culture but its main channel, systematically renamed as it flows. Sixty years on the sentence reads less as provocation than as an unremarkable summary of what happened to American popular music in the twentieth century.

Ellison’s Objection

Ralph Ellison reviewed the book in the New York Review of Books in February 1964, and the review has become as famous as the book. Ellison began generously, crediting Jones with taking his subject seriously as the best jazz critics always had, and with attempting to place the blues within a total culture through sociology, anthropology and history — though he noted that Jones seriously underrated the last of these.

Then came the line everyone quotes: “The tremendous burden of sociology which LeRoi Jones would place upon this body of music is enough to give even the blues the blues.” Ellison’s substantive objection was to the separatism implicit in Baraka’s framework — a distinct Black American culture standing apart from the mainstream, with blues and jazz as the hermetic expression of a marginalised sensibility. American culture, Ellison countered, has always been pluralistic, and it is hard to imagine a period in which Black Americans were not shaping its mainstream. Most pointedly, he argued that by treating the subject sociologically Jones had missed what the music actually was: music was what the slaves had instead of freedom, and the blues, later, were what Black Americans had instead of religion.

Who Was Right

The exchange is one of the essential arguments in American criticism, and it does not resolve. Ellison is defending art against its reduction to social data — insisting that a blues is a made thing with its own internal life, not a symptom to be diagnosed. Baraka is insisting that a music produced under those specific conditions cannot be read as though the conditions were incidental, and that calling the culture pluralistic is a comfortable way of declining to name who took what from whom.

Both positions have been thoroughly vindicated by subsequent scholarship, which is the honest verdict. What is not in dispute is the book’s structural effect. Blues People established that African American music could be the subject of serious intellectual history written from inside, and every subsequent study of the field is downstream of it, including those that argue with it. Ellison won the argument about how to read a single blues; Baraka won the argument about how to read the century that produced them.

Baraka and the Beats

Baraka wrote the book while still embedded in the downtown New York avant-garde, editing little magazines, publishing Beat writers, married to Hettie Jones, part of the circle around Ginsberg and Frank O’Hara. Blues People was published the year before Malcolm X’s assassination changed his direction entirely and he left that world for Harlem and Black nationalism. He was, at the time of writing, one of the most visible Black figures in a self-consciously integrated literary scene.

Read in that light the book is a hinge. Its subject — a culture producing genius that another culture profitably renames — is not only a thesis about music. It is a young writer working out, in scholarly form, what his position in a white bohemia actually was. The Beats had made jazz their central metaphor for spontaneity and freedom. Baraka wrote the book explaining what the music had actually cost, and then left.

The tremendous burden of sociology which LeRoi Jones would place upon this body of music is enough to give even the blues the blues.

Ralph Ellison, review of Blues People, The New York Review of Books, 6 February 1964

Where to go next

Read Ellison’s full review in the New York Review of Books, then his essay collection Shadow and Act, where the counter-argument is developed at length.


Previous: Jane Bowles, Two Serious Ladies. Next: Anais Nin, Diary of Anais Nin, Volume One. One hundred books from the Beat Generation and the writers around them — the ones who got famous, the ones who got written out, and the ecological writing that grew out of the same soil. A new one every other day.

Sources

CD Damitio writes INDIGNIFIED — utopias and dystopias explored. Free to read.

Read on Substack →  |  Full catalog →